What Happened to Barbara Newhall Follett? The 1939 Mystery

On December 7, 1939, a famous young American author walked out of her apartment with thirty dollars in her pocket and disappeared forever.

How could a brilliant literary prodigy vanish into thin air without leaving a single physical trace behind?

A vintage 1930s typewriter and paper manuscripts sitting on an old wooden desk

What We Know

Barbara Newhall Follett was born in New Hampshire in 1914 and showed extraordinary talent at a very early age. By the time she was twelve years old, she published her first novel, The House Without Windows, with a major publishing house in 1927. The book received widespread critical praise across the United States, launching her into the spotlight as a child literary prodigy.

Her early success was followed by a second published book in 1928, but her family life soon faced severe personal and financial challenges. As the Great Depression took hold in the early 1930s, Barbara moved between cities and took secretarial jobs to support herself while continuing to write in private.

In 1933, Barbara married a man named Rogers Rogers, and the couple eventually settled in Brookline, Massachusetts. On the evening of December 7, 1939, following a heated personal argument with her husband, twenty-five-year-old Barbara walked out of their shared apartment carrying only thirty dollars in cash and a small notebook.

Her husband did not formally report her missing to the police until April 1940, several months after her departure. Because the official missing persons bulletin was listed under her married name, Barbara Rogers, newspapers failed to connect the case to the famous former child author, and no physical clues were ever discovered.

A quiet, empty town street at night during winter

The Theories

Theory 1: Starting a New Life Under an Assumed Identity One major theory suggests that Barbara intentionally chose to abandon her past and start over under a fake name. She was an experienced traveler who had previously spent months living on ships and working in different towns. Proponents of this explanation believe she may have moved across the country, secured work using a new alias, and chosen to live out her life in quiet anonymity.

Theory 2: Victim of Foul Play or Exposure Another common theory involves foul play or a sudden accident shortly after she walked away from her home. Walking alone late at night in December carried natural risks, and investigators could not rule out a fatal accident or violent crime. However, because law enforcement was not notified until four months later, any potential search area or physical evidence was lost long before an investigation began.

Theory 3: Despair and Voluntary Disappearance Some historians and family members speculated that Barbara suffered from deep emotional distress after her marriage strained and her writing career stalled. In letters sent to friends shortly before her disappearance, she voiced sadness regarding her personal life and career trajectory. Some researchers believe she may have walked into a remote natural area, explaining why searchers never located her remains.

An open notebook and vintage fountain pen on a table

More than eight decades after Barbara Newhall Follett walked out into the cold night of December 1939, her fate remains completely unknown. Did she successfully build a secret new existence under an assumed name, or did tragedy strike her on the very night she left home? Until official records or physical evidence surface, the final chapter of this celebrated young author will remain completely unwritten.

Post a Comment

0 Comments